Some quantitative variables are discrete, such as performance rated as 1,2,3,4, or 5, or temperature rounded to the nearest degree. In this case, a prior such as beta1,1 may be used for the stratumspecific probability. Missing data using stata basics for further reading many methods assumptions assumptions ignorability. Most variables in the dataset suffer from missing values, so i used amelia ii to impute the data. Correlation between discrete variable the r graph gallery. How to impute the dependent variable an independent. For each simulated data set, with missing data imposed according to the mechanisms described, we estimated the regression model of interest using completecase analysisthat is, restricting the data to cases where all required variables were observed, and using multiple imputation, performed with mvni or fcs.
The variable with missing data is used as the dependent variable. This frequently asked question faq assumes familiarity with multiple imputation. I am dealing with a somewhat large dataset about 40 relevant variables and about 8000 observations based on survey responses. One of those methods for creating multiple imputations is predictive mean matching pmm, a general purpose method. Comparison of methods for imputing limitedrange variables. But, as i explain below, its also easy to do it the wrong way. Data are missing on some variables for some observations problem. Most multiple imputation methods assume multivariate normality, so a common question is how to impute missing values from categorical variables. For some variables in certain datasets, their corresponding marginal distributions in the population can be obtained from external data sources e.
The stata impute command uses ols to estimate missing values, appropriate only for continuous variables. Initially, it all depends upon how the data is coded as to which variable type it is. Remember the dependent variable in one part of the analysis might be independent in another. With 110% missingness per variable, you can add a few variables without loosing to big a proportion of your data. For a categorical variable, ologit can be used to impute missing categories.
Much of the literature concerns the problem of imputing a binary or other discrete incomplete variable within strata defined by one or more other discrete variables rubin and schenker, 1986. Sep 30, 2016 as an econometrician i can give you examples related to that. If our study samples in truth come from such a population, the population information can be fed into the imputation model to calibrate inference to the population. Theoretically, i could use logit and multinomial logit models, with the predict command, to obtain predicted values for missing cases. Policy makers cannot randomize taxation, for example. To install the latest version click on the following link. Also, if your data have already been imputed, see the documentation entry mi mi import on how to import your data to mi and see mi mi estimate on how to analyze your multiply imputed data. The comparisons show that these multiple imputation methods are the most appropriate to handle missing values in a multilevel setting and why their relative performances can vary according to the missing data pattern, the multilevel structure and the type of missing variables.
Categorical variables with k levels are supposed to be represented with k 1 dummies in the dataset. A simulation study of a linear regression with a response y and two predictors x1 and x 2 was performed on data with n 50, 100 and 200 using complete cases or multiple imputation with 0, 10, 20, 40 and 80. Multiple imputation for continuous and categorical data. For example, hair color would be a discrete variable, because it can only have a limited number of values, such as red, brown, and black, that does not occur in any particular. The mict package provides a method for multiple imputation of categorical timeseries data such as life course or employment status histories that preserves longitudinal consistency, using a mono. Multipleimputation analysis using statas mi command. One variable type for which mi may lead to implausible values is a limitedrange variable. For example, if i am creating a multivariate equation with an independent variable and a dependent variable, and wish to introduce a third variable as a control variable, would it be correct to use. Continuous variables can meaningfully have an infinite number of possible values, limited only by your resolution and the range on which theyre defined. Stata doesnt offer pairwise deletion, so id have to code this up myself.
To achieve that goal, imputed values should preserve the structure in the data, as wel. Imputing clustered data in stata imputation with cluster dummies imputation in wide form imputation via random effects. In the output from mi estimate you will see several metrics in the upper right hand corner that you may find unfamilar these parameters are estimated as part of the imputation and allow the user to assess how well the imputation performed. I did not need to create dummy variables, interaction terms, or polynomials. This is part four of the multiple imputation in stata series. Paul allison, one of my favorite authors of statistical information for researchers, did a study that showed that the most common method actually gives worse results that listwise deletion. Hello, i have a data set that has some categorical variables both binary outcome variables and variables having more than two categories and some continuous variables. A type of variable, also called a categorical or nominal variable, which has a finite number of possible values that do not have an inherent order.
Cases with complete data for the predictor variables are used to generate the regression equation. Please see the documentation entries mi intro substantive and mi intro if you are unfamiliar with the method. Data imputation in r with nas in only one variable categorical. In the absence of experimental data, an option is to use instrumental variables or a control function approach. I need to deal with missing data for noncontinuous variables. Multiple imputation for a single incomplete variable works by constructing an imputation model relating the incomplete variable to other variables and drawing from the posterior predictive distribution of the missing data conditional on the observed data. And then i want to perform a linear regression for them. Jan 26, 2016 multiple imputation by chained equations. Now i have five imputed datasets stata 14 format with no missing values.
Audigier, white, jolani, debray, quartagno, carpenter. Auxiliary variables in multiple imputation in regression with. Avoiding bias due to perfect prediction in multiple. After these dummies are multiple imputed using multivariate normal regression mi impute mvn, mi mvncat assigns values 0 or 1 to each dummy, ensuring that dummies representing one categorical variable add up to 1.
Theoretical considerations as well as simulation studies have shown that the inclusion of auxiliary variables is generally of benefit. Further update of ice, with an emphasis on categorical variables. However, i realised the imputed values do not replace the missing values in the original variables. Multiple imputation for categorical time series brendan. The multivariate normal model implemented in mi impute mvn assumes all variables follow a multivariate normal distribution.
Jul 27, 2012 hello, i have a data set that has some categorical variables both binary outcome variables and variables having more than two categories and some continuous variables. The joint modeling approach simply treats all functional terms as separate variables and imputes them together with the underlying imputation variables using a multivariate model, often a multivariate normal model. Factorvariable notation allows stata to identify interactions and to distinguish between discrete and continuous variables to obtain correct marginal effects. Analysis of imputed datasets in stata 14 cross validated. Compared with standard methods based on linear regression and the normal distribution, pmm produces. Multiple imputation of discrete and continuous data by fully. What are examples of discrete variables and continuous variables.
Multiple imputation of discrete and continuous data by fully conditional specification. Predictive mean matching pmm is an attractive way to do multiple imputation for missing data, especially for imputing quantitative variables that are not normally distributed. Minimize bias maximize use of available information get good estimates of uncertainty. Jul 12, 2016 i did not need to create dummy variables, interaction terms, or polynomials. For a list of topics covered by this series, see the introduction. This article is part of the multiple imputation in stata series. Additionally, while it is the case that single imputation and complete case are easier to implement, multiple imputation is not very difficult to implement. Consequently, fcs mi is particularly appealing in settings in which a number of variables have missing data, some of which are continuous and some of which are discrete. Choose from univariate and multivariate methods to impute missing values in continuous, censored, truncated, binary, ordinal, categorical, and count variables. How to impute interactions, squares and other transformed variables. A data set can contain indicator dummy variables, categorical variables andor both. By imputing multiple times, multiple imputation certainly accounts for the uncertainty and range of values that the true value could have taken. Spssx discussion imputation of categorical missing values.
An usual scatterplot would suffer overplotting when used for discrete variables. For a list of topics covered by this series, see the introduction this section will talk you through the details of the imputation process. I can use spss to impute missing values for continuous variables by em algorithm. How to impute the dependent variable an independent variables. The workaround suggested here makes dot size proportional to the number of datapoints behind it. The first is proc mi where the user specifies the imputation model to be used and the number of imputed datasets to be created. Multiple imputation is becoming increasingly popular. The second procedure runs the analytic model of interest here it is a linear regression using proc glm within each of the imputed datasets. As an econometrician i can give you examples related to that. Stata has many builtin estimators to implement these potential solutions and tools to construct estimators for situations that are not covered by builtin estimators. Multiple imputation of categorical variables the analysis. I am very naive and your other suggestions are beyond my understanding. Multiple imputation methods properly account for the uncertainty of missing data. This article contains examples that illustrate some of the issues involved in using multiple imputation.
How to do statistical analysis when data are missing. Within the applied setting, it remains unclear how important it is that imputed values should be plausible for individual observations. Jan 31, 2018 the best predictors are selected and used as independent variables in a regression equation. Multiple imputation for a single incomplete variable works by constructing an imputation model relating the incomplete variable to other variables and drawing from the posterior predictive distribution of. Multiple imputation of covariates by fully conditional. Suppose we have 2 discrete variables x and y, and there is ignorable missing data on x. And plus pairwise deletion as you said in another thread pairwise deletion generates worse biases than listwise according to allison 2002. For example, a categorical variable like marital status could be coded in the data set as a single variable with 5 values. Multiple imputation for incomplete data with semicontinuous. Multiple imputation of multiple multiitem scales when a full.
Multiplying variables generating new variables after mi. Independent variable are you prone to binge drinking 1yes, 2no dependent variable drinking and driving 1. In addition to the primary variables attack and smokes, the dataset contains. Ibrahim showed that, under the assumption that the missing data are missing at random, the e step of the em algorithm for any generalized linear model can be expressed as a weighted completedata loglikelihood when the unobserved covariates are assumed to come from a.
The best predictors are selected and used as independent variables in a regression equation. What is the relation between the official multipleimputation command, mi. We use a probit model to create binary variables for the second case, an ordered probit model to create ordinal variables for the third case, and a multinomial probit model to create unorderedcategorical variables for the fourth case. Variables that can only take on a finite number of values are called discrete variables. This module should be installed from within stata by typing ssc install. By default, stata provides summaries and averages of these values but the individual estimates can be obtained using the vartable. Because ice, mi ice, and mim are not part of official stata, you should install them separately. Relation between official mi and communitycontributed.
I am trying to understand the definition of a control variable in statistics. Recently i used multiple imputation to handle missing data, but my missingness occurs on both the dependent variables and independt variables, could i still use multiple imputation. Accordingly, the outcome variable should always be present in the imputation model. The goal of multiple imputation is to provide valid inferences for statistical estimates from incomplete data. However, it may not be a good idea to use the imputed values when the variable is dependent. Multiplying variables generating new variables after. I also want to impute a discrete variable, namely the age of companies in years integers with a maximum of 37 years age has only been measured as of 1967. If a passive variable is determined by regular variables, then it can be treated as a regular variable since no imputation is needed. Also, in addition to all the variables that may be used in the analysis model, you should include any auxiliary variables that may contain information about missing data. As we will see below, convenience is not the only reason to use factorvariable notation. A new imputation method for incomplete binary data.
59 1317 443 562 145 171 675 1144 855 778 108 1314 770 1293 1619 1594 1504 1565 1604 973 1497 668 1136 42 1129 535 244 1301 21 1272 1266 96 694 689 1473 618 512 262 1130